Waterproof Eyeliner Battle : Senegence VS Stila VS MAD

Posted by Dreamie Chuppa July 18, 2015

Waterproof Eyeliner Battle : Senegence VS Stila VS MAD

All of us must dream about a waterproof and smudge proof eyeliner which will stay all day long in our eyelid. So do i. i've been purchasing so many brands to find which eyeliner is the best for me.
First, lemme tell ya that i have a great oily eyelid that makes me cant use any pencil or gel eyeliner. it will smudge like crazy in my eyelid.
after for so long trying pencil, liquid and gel eyeliner,, throw away this and that eyeliner into my trash, finally i found the perfect eyeliner for me. the eyeliner that i dont need to worry it will smudge and ruin my eye make up. my best mate is the LIQUID eyeliner since i have a great oily eyelid. Pencil and gel eyeliner will smudge like crazy in my eyelid.

so after trying this and that, throw that and this eyeliner into the garbage
well, i have my 3 best eyeliners that i will absolutely repurchase of even stock them in my drawer

i cant decide which one of them is the best since each of them has "something" good

LOL. FYI, if i already found the best eyeliner (in my opinion), i'll stick on that eyeliner until i found the better one.. ahahahahhahahahahhaa

That's why you'll only see a few brand of eyeliner that i use in my FOTD so far

So... now lemme introduce you to my fave eyeliners

Senegence Eyesense #Brown

a dipped-brush eyeliner in a small clear tubewhere you can see the product

the brown is more bold rather than the black one. i dont have any idea why it can be like that
i ever made a review on the black one, you can read my review --> HERE

it has the smallest tube among all. This kind of eyeliner needs more time to apply since you cant just make a perfect bold eyeliner in single swipe
about it's lasting power? it's superb..!! no smudge, super waterproof, easily to remove

Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner #Black

is my only pen eyeliner that i loooooooooooooovvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee so bad. it is supa dupa ultra easy to use, jet black, waterproof, smudgeproof, dry quickly, long lasting, remove easily.. as stated in it's name "STAY ALL DAY" STILA really means it. This eyeliner stay all day long in my oily eyelid without smudge or does transfer

Though Stila is a bit pricey, yet i don't mind to pay since i get a really really incredible result

MAD 3 in 1 Liquid Eyeliner #Pandora

my super ffaaaaaaavvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee and holy grail eyeliner (thank's to my friends who introduce me to this incredible brand)
it's a dipped-brush eyeliner with a super jet black result which super waterproof and super long last. Different with my eyesense, this MAD doesn't need too many applications to get a great jet black color. yaappzz.. i just need a single swipe. Yet, it is not quickly dry as my eyesense. This MAD eyeliner need a longer time to perfectly dry. It does transfer when not completely dry. it's so sad

but dont worry, if it's completely dry,, it will stay on your eyelid forever and ever and ever and ever. even when you wanna remove it.. woakakakkakaka xDD i swear!! it's a bit hard to remove

swatch : 1x Stila - 1x MAD -3x Eyesense

they all are matte

can you see which one is the blackest?

Waterproof test under the running water

they stay still in their place. Not fade at all

all of them are smudge proof. yet, MAD is the only one which need some time to perfectly dry
so when MAD is not completely dry, it does transfer and a bit smudge. But it's not a big problem, you can remove it with your finger

see what i mean by "stay forever in your eyelid"?

senegence and stila are fade out when i rub them using a tissue and bare fingers several times, while MAD is still there

as i said before, SENEGENCE EYESENSE and STILA are easily to remove. it just need a single swipe (or twice) to remove the eyeliner and clean up the rest. Yet, MAD eyeliner is the most hard to remove. i need several swipes to remove it completely. Maybe, if i don't remove it in the end of my day, the next morning i don't need to apply eyeliner again #slap

MWAHAHAHAHAHAA

So, as a conclusion :
The most jet black --> MAD liquid eyeliner
The easiest to use --> STILA pen eyeliner
The most waterproof --> ALL
The most smudge proof --> ALL
My most fave --> ALL
The most long lasting --> MAD liquid eyeliner

Price (when this post is made)

Senegence Eyesense - IDR 225.000

Stila Stay All day liquid eyeliner - IDR 300.000

MAD 3in1 liquid eyeliner - IDR 175.000

Order :

FB : Dreamie Chuppa (www.facebook.com/dreamie.chuppa)

IG : @depth_dreamie ; @dreamiechu

Line : depth_dreamie